On Sunday afternoon Paul (WINOL),
greynolds and I had a huge game of Pirates of the Spanish Main. Here's a picture of the board with our lovely pirate ships setting sail to do battle and plunder treasure:

Paul and
greynolds were using 80 point fleets that Paul had worked out previously. I had decided to try something different: a massive fleet of cheap ships, so I outnumbered them 2 to 1. This was partly an experiment to see if this strategy would work. I even played some French ships as some of the cheapest ships I own are French.
I can now, on good authority, say that this strategy is a complete steaming pile of poo, and that I got my arse utterly kicked. Here are some of my ships about to engage ONE of Paul's ships (it's the large one on the left):

and here are the dismasted derelicts of my ships a couple of turns later:

One ship is missing due to it being sunk. You'll note his ship is completely undamaged. Oh dear. I will make one excuse, in that there's a particular crew piece in Pirates called "Captain", which you can add to your ship, which allows it to both move *and* fire in the same turn. Most of the other ships had this. My minimalist cheap ships had precisely zero additional crew elements, and could therefore only move *or* fire. This turned out to be a rather serious weakness. I hadn't actually realised there was such a crew piece before the game commenced. I don't own one and I hadn't noticed the effects when reading the rules.
Of course, now I'm thinking... How about a massive fleet of cheap ships where they all have captains? :-)
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)

Paul and
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
I can now, on good authority, say that this strategy is a complete steaming pile of poo, and that I got my arse utterly kicked. Here are some of my ships about to engage ONE of Paul's ships (it's the large one on the left):

and here are the dismasted derelicts of my ships a couple of turns later:

One ship is missing due to it being sunk. You'll note his ship is completely undamaged. Oh dear. I will make one excuse, in that there's a particular crew piece in Pirates called "Captain", which you can add to your ship, which allows it to both move *and* fire in the same turn. Most of the other ships had this. My minimalist cheap ships had precisely zero additional crew elements, and could therefore only move *or* fire. This turned out to be a rather serious weakness. I hadn't actually realised there was such a crew piece before the game commenced. I don't own one and I hadn't noticed the effects when reading the rules.
Of course, now I'm thinking... How about a massive fleet of cheap ships where they all have captains? :-)